Temperature and Marinade
The secret to a great tasting steak is often how it’s handled before it ever reaches the pan. The steak should be brought out of the refrigerator at least an hour before cooking so that it can reach room temperature throughout. Never try to cook a frozen steak. If the meat has been frozen, then it should be thawed in the refrigerator overnight or until it is completely thawed. Do not thaw steaks or any meat for that matter, in water or the microwave. Thawing in water may contaminate the meat or lead to bacterial growth. Thawing in a microwave or oven will cook the outside of the meat before the inside is thawed, ruining the steak. This wait time is also an excellent opportunity to add marinades to the steak.

While top sirloin steaks are usually considered grill steaks and are tender enough not to require a marinade, they can add great flavor for a truly above average meal. The choice of whether or not to marinade is often one of flavor and appearance. The marinade will probably change the look of the sear on the outside of the steak. A variety of marinades can be used depending on the desired flavor, and it’s not hard to make your own. It is important to give the marinade long enough to penetrate into the meat without breaking down the outside of the steak or over tenderizing it. Just place the steak in a bag filled with the marinade, work it around a bit to get a nice coating, and let it sit. The time it takes the meat to reach optimal room temperature is just long enough to impart some extra flavor to the meat, so it fits nicely with the rest of the process.

Paper Towel Prep

Once the steak has reached room temperature throughout, pat it down with a paper towel to remove excess moisture. This helps with the sear. If a marinade was used, the paper towel step is still important to ensure excessive amounts of the marinade are not left on the steak. Excessive marinade or pieces of the marinade ingredients may char on the outside of the steak, creating a bitter flavor.

Salt Before Cooking

There is a long-standing argument about whether steak should be salted before or after cooking. Although this case has been mostly settled by food scientists, it is still common to hear that salting can draw moisture and flavor out of the meat. It was found that the opposite is true. The salt firms the outside of the steak and prevents the loss of moisture and flavor, so remember that despite what you may hear, always salt your steak before cooking. A pinch or two of salt on each side is ideal. Kosher salt is a nice choice because its flavor is milder, but any salt can be used. Just be careful not to over-salt the meat.

Heating the Pan
As in many beef recipes, an often-overlooked step is to have the frying pan properly heated before placing the meat in it. Heating the oil in the pan has several critical advantages. It ensures the meat has a proper sear and seal the moment it hits the pan. This locks the juices inside where they are supposed to be. It also prevents excess oil from seeping into the steak.

Heat the pan with about a tablespoon of cooking oil or butter in it. The oil you use can vary, but it is important to choose something that can stand up to high heat without burning or making an off flavor. Coconut oil or ghee is usually the best choice. You will know the oil is ready when it begins emitting faint white smoke. Olive oil is not recommended due to its lower smoking point.

Why Use a Cast Iron Frying Pan?

The use of cast iron pans is universally recommended for stove top cooking. It has excellent heat retention properties, and it can be seasoned to produce a nearly non-stick surface. Here is a short list of reasons to use cast iron frying pans:

  1. Even heat distribution. Cast iron creates an even, intense heat across the total pan surface. This helps seal in juices to keep the meat moist and flavorful.
  2. They are versatile. You can use a cast iron pan to deep fry or sauté or to bake in. It’s just as handy as a baking pan in the oven as it is a grilling pan on the stove top.
  3. Cost Saving. Cast iron pans are less expensive than steel or other metal pans. And one cast iron pan can do the jobs that other metal pans require a number of different pans to accomplish.
  4. Long lasting. Cast iron pans are durable and have a long lifespan. They are often passed down from generation to generation. And unlike other pans, old and worn cast iron pieces can usually be refurbished with a good scrubbing.
  5. Non-stick. Once a cast iron pan is seasoned correctly, food won’t stick to it. It also does not give off toxic fumes that non-stick pans do.
  6. Easy to clean. A stiff brush and hot water will do the trick.

How to Season your Cast Iron Cookware

New cast-iron skillets need to be seasoned properly to develop that non-stick surface. Here are the steps necessary to accomplish that:

  1. Preheat the oven to 325°F.
  2. Use warm, soapy water to wash the skillet. Use a sponge or stiff brush to thoroughly clean. This is the only time you’ll want to use soap. Once the pan is seasoned, soap is never used when cleaning after use.Rinse and pat dry with paper towels.
  3. Rub the pan with a thin coating of flax seed oil on a paper towel or soft rag.
  4. Place the pan in the preheated oven with the skillet upside down on the center rack.
  5. Place a baking pan on the rack below the pan to catch drips.
  6. Bake at 325°F for sixty minutes.
  7. Turn off oven. Allow the pan to cool down completely to room temperature, usually about two hours, then remove the pan from the oven.
  8. For maximum results and to achieve a superior seasoned coating, repeat the process three or four more times or until the cast iron has a dark, semi-matte finish.

Restaurant Style Cooking a Thick Steak on Your Stove Top

For steaks that are extra thick, you might try using a style of cooking many upscale restaurants use called Sous-vide. In this form of cooking, the chef seals the steak in an airtight plastic bag, then places the bag in a bath of temperature-controlled hot water. Water kept at a temperature of between 131ºF to 140 °F will cook the meat to medium-rare finish but not beyond. The purpose of sous-vide is to cook the meat from the inside to ensure that the middle of the extra thick steak is properly cooked without having to char or overcook the outside layer. Just before serving, the steak is removed from the plastic bag and placed on a hot cast iron skillet for a short time until you get that crisp, dark crust on the top and bottom. The inside remains a beautiful medium-rare pink.