Gently place the steak in the center of the heated pan and welcome the loud sizzle. It’s important to be patient and precise with this step; don’t fuss over the steak. It should be turned as little as possible, preferably only once. The exact cooking times vary depending on the desired level of doneness. The traditional medium-rare level can be achieved with about three minutes of cooking on each side. Decrease by about a minute per side for rare, and increase a minute or two on each side for medium and well done.

A meat thermometer is your best friend when cooking a steak. You want to avoid cutting into the steak to check for doneness because this ruins the appearance and release all the juices and flavor into the pan. Since cooking times can vary due to many factors, tracking temperature instead of time is always the best approach. An internal temperature of 130-135ºF is optimal for medium rare. Be sure to jab the thermometer as close to the middle of the steak as possible for the best reading.

Resting
Resting a steak allows the juices, which have gone wild during cooking, to redistribute throughout the meat and settle. If the steak is cut into before this happens, the juices will flow out of the steak, and you will be left with a dry and flavorless meat. The steak should be placed under a tent-shaped piece of aluminum foil for about 5 minutes to rest. The foil is important to prevent the outside of the steak from cooling off too much. After resting, plate the steak and sprinkle with coarse ground pepper and any additional garnish.